Revelation Prophecy Commentary
Reading Progress 95%
📖 Part 36 of 38

Revelation 6:3–4 Commentary: The Second Seal, the Red Horse, Peace Taken from the Earth, and the Great Sword of War | Essay 36

Revelation VerseQuest Commentary

Essay 36: Peace Is Taken from the Earth, and Men Become One Another’s Executioners

Text: Revelation 6:3–4

There is something terribly revealing about the second seal of Revelation because it demonstrates how quickly the appearance of civilization can disappear when the conditions supporting peace are removed. Revelation 6:3–4 declares, “And when he had opened the second seal, I heard the second beast say, Come and see. And there went out another horse that was red: and power was given to him that sat thereon to take peace from the earth, and that they should kill one another: and there was given unto him a great sword.” The first rider appeared upon a white horse, carrying a bow, receiving a crown, and going forth conquering and to conquer. Now another horse appears, and its rider receives authority to remove peace from the earth. THE WORLD THAT WAS JUST WATCHING A CONQUEROR ADVANCE NOW DISCOVERS WHAT HAPPENS WHEN PEACE IS TAKEN AWAY! The progression is unmistakable. Conquest is followed by bloodshed, and mankind begins destroying mankind.

The wording deserves careful attention because John does not simply announce that a war begins somewhere upon the earth. He records that power is given to the second rider “to take peace from the earth.” There is a tremendous difference between describing an isolated military conflict and announcing the removal of peace itself. Nations have repeatedly congratulated themselves upon their treaties, institutions, military strength, commercial agreements, and political arrangements. Men imagine that civilization has become sufficiently advanced to guarantee permanent stability through their own wisdom. Yet Scripture presents peace as something that may be taken away under divine judgment. MAN CAN BUILD AN IMPRESSIVE CIVILIZATION, BUT HE CANNOT GUARANTEE THAT THE HEARTS OF ITS INHABITANTS WILL REMAIN PEACEFUL! When restraint gives way and violence spreads, the same human beings who celebrated their progress may become one another’s executioners. Revelation exposes the dreadful insecurity beneath mankind’s confident declarations of lasting peace.

The second seal also establishes an indispensable truth concerning the sovereignty of Jesus Christ. The rider does not seize the heavenly book, break its seal, or independently determine when the judgments shall begin. The Lamb opens the seal, one of the four living creatures summons John to observe, and the red horse appears within the unfolding prophetic vision. The authority granted to its rider remains subordinate to the government of Almighty God. Yet the resulting slaughter involves human beings killing one another, demonstrating the terrible distinction between divine judgment and the wicked actions through which that judgment unfolds. THE LAMB CONTROLS THE SEAL, BUT THE MEN WHO SLAUGHTER ONE ANOTHER ARE NOT THEREBY EXCUSED FROM THEIR BLOODGUILTINESS! The chapter presents a world increasingly overcome by the consequences of rebellion, where counterfeit conquest gives way to open violence and the peace mankind boasted of possessing proves incapable of surviving apart from divine restraint.

1. The Second Seal Opens: The Lamb Still Controls the Coming Judgments

Revelation 6:3 begins, “And when he had opened the second seal.” The identity of the One opening the seal is established by the preceding verses. Revelation 6:1 expressly identifies the Lamb as the One who opened the first seal, and the continuing sequence maintains His authority over the sealed book. Revelation 5 already established that no created being was worthy to take the book from Almighty God’s right hand. The Lion of the tribe of Juda prevailed, John beheld the Lamb as it had been slain, and the heavenly assembly proclaimed His worthiness. THE SECOND SEAL DOES NOT OPEN BECAUSE THE FIRST HORSEMAN HAS SOMEHOW GAINED CONTROL OF HEAVEN’S GOVERNMENT! The Lamb remains the One exercising authority. Every horseman must be interpreted within that governing context, regardless of the destructive conduct associated with the events that follow. Heaven has not surrendered its throne to the ambitions of earthly rulers.

The second of the four living creatures announces, “Come and see.” Revelation 4:7 distinguished the four creatures by their remarkable appearances, while Revelation 4:8 described their six wings and continual declaration of God’s holiness. These beings participated in the worship surrounding the Lamb before the sealed book began to open. Now their voices accompany the unfolding judgments. The second creature does not receive authority to invent the next event or independently determine the earth’s future. He summons John to behold what is revealed. HEAVEN’S LIVING CREATURES ARE NOT RUNNING AN UNAUTHORIZED GOVERNMENTAL DEPARTMENT WHERE THEY ISSUE JUDGMENTS WITHOUT CONSULTING THE KING! Their activity belongs to the order established around Almighty God’s throne. John remains the appointed witness, receiving the revelation rather than manufacturing its contents. His responsibility is to record what the Lord shows him, preserving the words and distinctions supplied by the Holy Ghost.

The distinction between God’s sovereignty and human wickedness is essential. Isaiah 10:5 identifies Assyria as the rod of God’s anger in a particular historical judgment, yet Isaiah 10:12 subsequently announces judgment upon the arrogant heart of the Assyrian king. Habakkuk 1 likewise demonstrates that the LORD may employ a wicked nation within His purposes without approving that nation’s idolatry and cruelty. Those passages belong to Israel’s historical circumstances, but they establish an enduring principle concerning divine government. GOD’S ABILITY TO OVERRULE HUMAN REBELLION DOES NOT MAKE THE REBEL RIGHTEOUS! When the red horse appears and men begin killing one another, their violence remains evil. The Lamb’s opening of the seal establishes the authority under which the judgment unfolds; it does not convert murder into a righteous act merely because the event was foreknown and permitted by Almighty God.

2. Another Horse That Was Red: Bloodshed Follows the Appearance of Conquest

Revelation 6:4 announces, “And there went out another horse that was red.” The word “another” connects this appearance with the preceding white horse while distinguishing the new rider and his particular activity. Revelation 6:2 introduced a conqueror carrying a bow and receiving a crown. The second horseman now receives authority to remove peace and is associated with human slaughter. The color red naturally contributes to the picture of violence and bloodshed, especially when considered alongside the actions explicitly described in the same verse. THE FIRST HORSEMAN RIDES FORTH CONQUERING; THE SECOND APPEARS WHERE HUMAN BEINGS BEGIN KILLING ONE ANOTHER! This is not a vision of civilization steadily improving until mankind finally manufactures heaven upon earth. It is a prophetic movement into instability, fear, and bloodshed. The outward forms of organized society cannot prevent the terrible consequences of rebellion once the conditions of peace collapse.

The resemblance to earlier prophetic horse visions deserves examination. Zechariah 1:8 describes a man riding upon a red horse, with other horses present behind him. Zechariah 6:1–8 introduces horses of different colors associated with the four spirits of the heavens. Those passages demonstrate that horses and their colors appear within prophetic visions concerning divine activity. Nevertheless, the figures in Zechariah must not automatically be identified with every rider appearing in Revelation. The circumstances, descriptions, and assigned activities must be examined individually. A RED HORSE IN ONE PROPHETIC VISION DOES NOT GIVE THE INTERPRETER PERMISSION TO DRAG ITS RIDER INTO ANOTHER CHAPTER WITHOUT CHECKING WHETHER THE BIBLE HAS IDENTIFIED THEM AS THE SAME. Revelation 6 supplies its own decisive description. This rider receives power to take peace from the earth, and human beings begin killing one another. His assignment is inseparable from widespread violence.

The contrast between the white and red horses also exposes the deceptive expectations frequently associated with earthly conquest. Daniel 8:25 describes a future wicked ruler who “by peace shall destroy many,” while Daniel 11:21 records a ruler obtaining a kingdom peaceably through flatteries. These passages provide relevant background for understanding the prophetic pattern of deceptive advancement followed by destructive domination. The first horseman fits the interpretation of counterfeit conquest associated with the coming Antichrist, while the second reveals the removal of peace. Yet Revelation 6 does not state that the first rider personally hands authority to the second or that a particular diplomatic agreement expires at this exact moment. THE BIBLE GIVES US A SEQUENCE WITHOUT PROVIDING A TRANSCRIPT OF EVERY SECRET CONVERSATION BETWEEN FUTURE RULERS. The relationship is nevertheless significant: the outward promise of conquest is followed by the unmistakable reality of slaughter.

3. Peace Is Taken from the Earth: What Mankind Assumed It Possessed

The central expression of Revelation 6:4 is that power is given “to take peace from the earth.” This language emphasizes removal. Peace exists as a recognizable condition, and the rider receives authority to take it away. The passage does not present peace as something humanity has permanently secured through superior intelligence or political development. Jeremiah 6:14 records the LORD’s condemnation of those who healed the hurt of His people slightly, saying, “Peace, peace; when there is no peace.” That warning originally concerned Judah’s rebellious condition and approaching judgment, but its principle exposes the danger of false security. A GOVERNMENT CAN ANNOUNCE PEACE, A PREACHER CAN PROMISE PEACE, AND A CROWD CAN CHANT ABOUT PEACE WITHOUT ANY OF THEM POSSESSING THE POWER TO GUARANTEE IT! Words cannot preserve a condition that human rebellion is determined to destroy. Revelation presents peace as subject to divine judgment rather than permanent human ownership.

First Thessalonians 5:3 provides an especially important prophetic comparison: “For when they shall say, Peace and safety; then sudden destruction cometh upon them, as travail upon a woman with child; and they shall not escape.” Paul distinguishes those overtaken by the coming day from believers who are children of light and are instructed to remain watchful. The warning concerns deceptive security preceding destruction, not the promise that human diplomacy will prevent the day of the Lord. THE MOST DANGEROUS ANNOUNCEMENT IN PROPHECY MAY COME FROM PEOPLE WHO ARE ABSOLUTELY CONVINCED THAT NOTHING DANGEROUS IS ABOUT TO HAPPEN! The world can mistake a temporary absence of open conflict for a permanent settlement of its deeper rebellion. Revelation 6 demonstrates how quickly the supposed foundation of stability can disappear. When peace is taken, mankind discovers that its confidence was resting upon arrangements incapable of controlling the sinful heart.

The withdrawal of peace must also be distinguished from the introduction of isolated conflict. Wars existed long before Revelation’s future judgments, and Jesus warned in Matthew 24:6–7 of wars, rumours of wars, and nation rising against nation. That prophecy belongs to His discourse concerning the future and must be read according to its setting. Revelation 6:4 describes an event within the opening seals rather than every ordinary military dispute throughout history. The text says peace is taken “from the earth,” establishing a sweeping sphere for the judgment without supplying an exact number of nations, combatants, or casualties. THE HOLY GHOST DOES NOT REQUIRE A MODERN NEWS ANCHOR TO PROVIDE A LIST OF EVERY COUNTRY BEFORE THE WORDS “FROM THE EARTH” CAN BE TAKEN SERIOUSLY. The judgment reaches beyond an insignificant local quarrel. Its defining feature is the terrible removal of peace under the authority associated with the second seal.

4. Men Kill One Another: The Terrible Harvest of the Sinful Heart

The next expression is among the most disturbing in Revelation 6:4: “and that they should kill one another.” John does not merely describe the rider personally killing a multitude of victims. The wording emphasizes human beings participating in mutual slaughter. WHEN PEACE IS TAKEN, THE WORLD DISCOVERS THAT ITS GREATEST DANGER IS NOT ALWAYS A SUPERNATURAL MONSTER RISING FROM THE ABYSS. SOMETIMES THE DANGER IS THE MAN STANDING BESIDE HIS NEIGHBOR! The passage exposes the capacity for violence residing within fallen humanity. The rider’s granted authority becomes associated with conditions under which men destroy one another. Their participation is not incidental. It is expressly recorded as part of the judgment. The world that celebrated its sophistication and accomplishments becomes a place where human life is treated as expendable.

The biblical explanation for human violence reaches back to Genesis. Genesis 4:8 records Cain rising against Abel and slaying his own brother. The first recorded murder was not committed because mankind lacked advanced transportation, international diplomacy, or modern educational institutions. It arose from a sinful heart. James 4:1–2 asks where wars and fightings originate and answers by directing attention toward lusts that war within human members. James then declares, “ye kill, and desire to have, and cannot obtain.” CAIN DID NOT NEED A MILITARY ACADEMY TO TEACH HIM HOW TO HATE HIS BROTHER! The roots of slaughter lie deeper than weapons and political disagreements. Human covetousness, pride, hatred, and rebellion produce destructive actions when they are permitted to govern conduct. Revelation’s second seal exposes that terrible capacity on a widespread prophetic scale.

This does not mean every person caught within warfare possesses equal guilt or that victims of violence are responsible for the acts committed against them. Scripture distinguishes murderers from those they murder, aggressive rulers from the oppressed, and legitimate civil authority from criminal bloodshed. Genesis 9:6 establishes the seriousness of shedding innocent blood, while Romans 13:1–4 describes governing authority as responsible for punishing evil. Those passages cannot be twisted into permission for indiscriminate violence. THE FACT THAT GOD FOREKNOWS HUMAN SLAUGHTER DOES NOT MAKE EVERY KILLER INNOCENT, AND THE FACT THAT JUDGMENT FALLS UPON A WORLD DOES NOT MAKE EVERY VICTIM A PARTICIPANT IN THE SAME CRIME. Revelation emphasizes the removal of peace and the resulting slaughter, not a universal declaration of identical personal guilt. The responsibility of those who shed innocent blood remains established by the righteousness of Almighty God.

5. A Great Sword Is Given: Delegated Authority Does Not Produce Righteousness

Revelation 6:4 concludes, “and there was given unto him a great sword.” The wording parallels the earlier declaration that power was given to take peace from the earth. The rider receives a weapon associated with his destructive activity, and the sword is specifically described as great. Scripture repeatedly identifies swords with warfare, execution, and the exercise of deadly force. Ezekiel 21 contains extensive prophetic language concerning the sword of judgment against Jerusalem, while Jeremiah 25:31–33 describes the LORD’s controversy with the nations and the resulting slaughter. Those passages concern their own historical and prophetic settings, but they demonstrate the serious biblical associations of the sword. THE RED HORSEMAN DOES NOT RECEIVE A CEREMONIAL LETTER OPENER. HE RECEIVES A GREAT SWORD WHILE HUMAN BEINGS BEGIN KILLING ONE ANOTHER! The weapon reinforces the violent character of the judgment and the dreadful consequences of peace being removed.

The description also raises an important question concerning authority. John twice emphasizes that something is given to the rider. He receives power to remove peace, and he receives a great sword. Revelation 6:4 does not identify the immediate giver in either statement. The broader context establishes that the Lamb opens the seal under the sovereignty of Almighty God, but the verse does not provide a complete explanation of every instrument or intermediary involved in the judgment. A PREACHER WHO KNOWS THE NAME OF THE ANGEL THAT HANDED OVER THE SWORD HAS LEARNED SOMETHING JOHN DID NOT WRITE DOWN. The fact of delegated authority is clear; its precise mechanism remains undisclosed. What matters is that the rider does not possess unlimited independent sovereignty. His destructive mission unfolds within an appointed prophetic sequence and beneath the supreme authority of the One who opens the seals.

The sword also invites comparison with the authority of civil government, but the two must not be confused. Romans 13:4 describes the ruler as a minister of God who bears not the sword in vain, executing wrath upon those who do evil. That passage concerns the legitimate responsibility of governing authorities within the present order. The second seal, however, concerns a prophetic judgment in which peace is removed and men kill one another. A SWORD CAN BE USED TO RESTRAIN A MURDERER, AND A SWORD CAN BE USED BY A MURDERER. THE WEAPON DOES NOT MAKE THE MAN RIGHTEOUS! Authority must be evaluated according to its source, purpose, and obedience to God’s standards. The great sword of Revelation 6 belongs to the judgment’s terrible violence, not to an automatic endorsement of every ruler who possesses military force.

6. False Peace, True Peace, and the Prince Whose Kingdom Shall Not Fail

The removal of earthly peace raises a necessary doctrinal distinction. Scripture speaks of peace in several related but different settings. Romans 5:1 declares, “Therefore being justified by faith, we have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ.” That is peace established through justification, not a promise that redeemed believers will never experience earthly conflict. John 14:27 records Jesus declaring, “Peace I leave with you, my peace I give unto you: not as the world giveth, give I unto you.” John 16:33 likewise warns that believers shall have tribulation in the world while finding peace in Christ. A SINNER MAY LIVE IN A QUIET COUNTRY WHILE REMAINING AN ENEMY OF GOD, AND A SAVED MAN MAY LIVE AMID WAR WHILE POSSESSING PEACE WITH GOD THROUGH JESUS CHRIST! These truths must be distinguished. Revelation 6 concerns earthly peace being taken, not the cancellation of justification or eternal security for those who are in Christ.

Isaiah 9:6–7 identifies the promised Messiah as the Prince of Peace and declares that of the increase of His government and peace there shall be no end. Isaiah 2:4 describes the coming righteous order in which nations shall beat their swords into plowshares and shall not learn war any more. Micah 4:3–4 provides corresponding promises concerning the future reign and security associated with the LORD’s government. These passages must retain their connection to Israel’s prophetic hope and the future earthly kingdom. THE PRINCE OF PEACE WILL NOT NEED AN ANNUAL EMERGENCY CONFERENCE TO DISCOVER WHETHER HIS KINGDOM CAN SURVIVE ANOTHER YEAR! His government will rest upon righteousness and divine authority. The peace promised under Messiah’s reign is fundamentally different from the temporary arrangements established by sinful rulers who remain unable to transform the rebellious human heart.

The distinction exposes a recurring error within both politics and religion. Men imagine that unity can be manufactured by suppressing truth, that wickedness can be restrained permanently through public relations, and that peace can exist indefinitely without righteousness. Yet Isaiah 48:22 declares, “There is no peace, saith the LORD, unto the wicked.” The statement belongs to its prophetic setting, but it demonstrates the inseparable relationship between wickedness and the absence of true peace. THE WORLD WANTS THE BENEFITS OF THE PRINCE OF PEACE WHILE REFUSING THE AUTHORITY OF THE PRINCE HIMSELF! It wants security without submission, prosperity without righteousness, and unity without truth. Revelation’s second seal reveals the dreadful inadequacy of that arrangement. When peace is taken, the impressive promises of men cannot prevent their own civilization from descending into bloodshed.

7. From the First Rider to the Second: The Counterfeit Kingdom Moves Toward Slaughter

The relationship between the first and second horsemen deserves careful attention. Revelation 6:2 introduced a rider upon a white horse, carrying a bow, receiving a crown, and going forth conquering and to conquer. The second rider now appears upon a red horse, receiving authority to remove peace from the earth and a great sword associated with mutual slaughter. The sequence naturally communicates movement from conquest into widespread violence. The interpretation connecting the first rider with the coming Antichrist is strengthened by the broader prophetic pattern of deceptive advancement followed by persecution and destructive dominion. THE MAN WHO ARRIVES OFFERING THE WORLD ITS DREAM OF SECURITY MAY BECOME THE VERY RULER UNDER WHOM THAT DREAM TURNS INTO A NIGHTMARE! Nevertheless, Revelation does not expressly say that the first rider personally commands the second or that both riders occupy the same earthly office.

Daniel 9:27 describes a future covenant confirmed for one week, with the cessation of sacrifice and oblation in the midst of the week. Daniel 11:21–24 describes the use of peaceable advancement and flatteries in a prophetic setting associated with a wicked ruler. Second Thessalonians 2:3–10 identifies the coming man of sin, his opposition to God, and the deceptive power accompanying his manifestation. Revelation 13 later reveals the Beast’s blasphemous dominion and persecution. These passages furnish substantial prophetic background for understanding the movement from apparent stability to destructive tyranny. THE ANTICHRIST WILL NOT ESTABLISH THE RIGHTEOUS KINGDOM OF GOD, REGARDLESS OF HOW MANY PEOPLE ACCEPT HIS CLAIMS OF AUTHORITY! His rebellion belongs to a temporary prophetic period that will end beneath Christ’s judgment. Yet Revelation 6:3–4 does not specify that the red horse appears at the midpoint of Daniel’s week, and that timing should not be manufactured from the color of the horse.

The second seal must also be understood within the proper dispensational framework. The Church’s promised catching away is revealed in First Thessalonians 4:16–17, while First Thessalonians 5 distinguishes believers from those overtaken by the coming day. Daniel’s seventieth week concerns the prophetic program involving Israel and Jerusalem, and the future Tribulation must not be confused with ordinary persecution throughout the Church Age. Revelation 19 will reveal Jesus Christ returning in righteousness to judge and make war, while Revelation 20 describes His thousand-year reign. THE RED HORSE DOES NOT REPRESENT THE FINAL TRIUMPH OF SATAN, AND THE GREAT SWORD DOES NOT CANCEL THE COMING KINGDOM OF THE PRINCE OF PEACE! The seals reveal judgments progressing beneath the authority of the Lamb. The counterfeit kingdom may advance through conquest and bloodshed, but its time remains limited, and the rightful King will establish the government that human rebellion could never produce.

Conclusion

Revelation 6:3–4 presents one of the most disturbing revelations concerning the collapse of earthly peace. The Lamb opens the second seal, the second living creature summons John to behold the vision, and a red horse appears. Its rider receives power to take peace from the earth, men begin killing one another, and a great sword is given to him. The wording is direct, and its implications are terrible. THE WORLD DISCOVERS THAT PEACE CAN BE REMOVED FASTER THAN HUMAN GOVERNMENTS CAN RESTORE IT! The judgment is not merely another example of the ordinary wars that have troubled human history. It belongs to the prophetic sequence initiated by the Lamb’s opening of the seals. The violence is widespread in its described sphere, deliberate in its character, and connected with the granted authority of the second rider. Yet the precise methods, timing, and complete human consequences remain beyond what these two verses explicitly disclose.

The passage also exposes the sinful condition of mankind and the inadequacy of peace established apart from righteousness. Men possess the capacity to build societies, establish laws, negotiate agreements, and develop impressive institutions. Those accomplishments may serve legitimate purposes, and Scripture recognizes the proper role of civil authority in restraining evil. Nevertheless, human organization cannot remove the sinful nature of fallen mankind. Cain murdered Abel long before modern warfare existed, and James identified the lusts and conflicts within the human heart as sources of violence. CIVILIZATION CAN TEACH A MAN TO BUILD A BETTER WEAPON WITHOUT TEACHING HIM WHY HE MUST NOT USE IT TO MURDER HIS NEIGHBOR! The second seal reveals the dreadful consequences of human rebellion when restraint collapses. Political stability is valuable, but it cannot substitute for reconciliation with God through Jesus Christ or establish the everlasting peace promised under Messiah’s righteous government.

And so the red horse rides, peace is taken from the earth, and men become one another’s executioners. The first horseman introduced conquest; the second reveals the bloodshed that follows. The great sword becomes a terrible expression of destructive authority, while the repeated statement that power was given reminds the reader that no earthly ruler possesses unlimited control over God’s purposes. The Lamb remains sovereign, the judgment remains appointed, and the violence of men remains morally accountable before Almighty God. THE WORLD MAY BELIEVE THAT PEACE BELONGS TO ITS GOVERNMENTS, ITS TREATIES, ITS ARMIES, AND ITS INSTITUTIONS, BUT REVELATION REVEALS HOW QUICKLY THAT CONFIDENCE CAN COLLAPSE! There is a peace that comes through justification by faith, and there is an everlasting peace that will characterize the righteous kingdom of Jesus Christ. Neither should be confused with the temporary stability of a rebellious world. The Prince of Peace will return, the wicked will be judged, and the promised kingdom will be established under His authority. THE SECOND SEAL TEACHES A LESSON THAT NO NATION SHOULD FORGET: MAN MAY CELEBRATE HIS ACHIEVEMENTS, BOAST OF HIS SECURITY, AND TRUST IN HIS OWN ARRANGEMENTS, BUT HE CANNOT GUARANTEE THAT HIS NEIGHBOR WILL NOT BECOME HIS MURDERER. THE LAMB OPENS THE SEAL, THE RED HORSE RIDES, THE GREAT SWORD APPEARS, AND THE WORLD DISCOVERS THAT PEACE WAS NEVER ITS PERSONAL PROPERTY. ONLY THE PRINCE OF PEACE CAN ESTABLISH A KINGDOM WHERE RIGHTEOUSNESS REIGNS AND WAR FINALLY ENDS!

Revelation Prophecy Commentary

Support This Free Study

✦

This VerseQuest PDF is available to everyone at no charge. These studies require significant time to research, write, format, maintain and distribute.

Choose $0 to download it freely, or give an optional amount to help us continue producing KJV Bible-study resources.

✓
📥
$0
Free Download
Receive this study
at no charge.
✓
❤️
$5
Help Support
This Study
Help with research,
formatting and
distribution.
✓
📖
$10
Help Fund More
Resources
Help us continue
creating free Bible
studies.
✓
🏛️
$15
Support the
VerseQuest Library
Help expand and
maintain our
growing library.
🔒 Secure & Safe
Your payment information is secure and never shared.